
Originally Posted by
.fX'
Hmm, came on here to see what level ED status is currently... and I gotta say, you got some work to do if you ever want to catch up with xF and Z mate, sorry to say, but Im not really seeing what other people see in you. Your old stuff was all pretty nice but your latest works seem to have gone a bit downhill imo.
The colab with kryla is ok, probably one of your better sigs but its not original, its been done before. The next colab is frankly awful, where did you ever get inspirartion to make such a n00by looking sig? Sorry if I sound harsh but the effects are just so basic and not worked with at all, and the contrast is way out. Terry sig is ok, but again, nothing unique here, same with Vagner Love, way too bright there as well, just a ton of light textures pasted over eachother. The icons are probably your better skill, some nice looking stuff in there and good range of techniques. The Messi sig is one of your better sigs, everything is really classy apart from the text, you could improve the position and effects imo. The Boston one, again, is overtextured, too many effects etc. Its like you're just adding textures for the hell of it. The text doesnt fit at all either.
Again, sorry if I seem a bit harsh (I like to check out the new ED or EDP stuff when they get promoted lol), but thats just the way I see your stuff. Its probably EDP level, but when you compare to Failure and Z its just not on the same wavelength, sorry buddy. I got heavily criticised when I used to make sigs like these because of all the textures I used then I realised that you gotta try new things when you make each sig, doesnt matter if it doesnt work out, but to reach the higher levels you have to do things that havent been done before or what other people cant do. For me everything here has been done before.
Hope my comments can help you out in some way, although you'll probably just ignore this because Im not saying how amazing your works are.
Congrats on getting ED though.